PSYC3004 Walden Pros & Cons of Diagnosing Psychological Disorders Paper
PSYC3004 Walden Pros & Cons of Diagnosing Psychological Disorders Paper
Main Discussion
Social media often entertains us with tests such as “Which Disney Animal Are You?”, “Which 80s Toy Are You?”, or “Which U.S. State Should You Live In?” While these tests are fun and can sometimes feel like an accurate depiction of one’s personality, they lack standardization, reliability, and validity. Clinical assessments are useful in gathering relevant information about a client’s experience and complaint. The information gathered must be accurate and helpful in informing diagnosis and treatment planning. This week you have the opportunity to review a sample clinical interview as well as take and critique two online psychological tests.
To prepare for this Discussion:
- Review the assigned chapter in your textbook, paying close attention to sections on assessment reliability and validity as well as clinical interviews.
- Read the Sample Unstructured Clinical Interview document and the Jones (2010) article provided in this week’s Learning Resources. Below is a copy of the sample.
The following Unstructured Clinical Interview is just a sample, and clinical interviews will vary by clinician and purpose. Most clinical interviews will gather the following data in varying order (Jones, 2010):
- Demographic and identifying information
- Presenting problem or chief complaint
- History of presenting problem
- Family history
- Relationship history
- Developmental history
- Educational history
- Work history
- Medical history
- Substance use
- Legal history
- Previous counseling
- Mental status examination (MSE)
Jones, K. D. (2010). The unstructured clinical interview. Journal of Counseling & Development, 88(2), 220–226.
Client Name: __________________________________________DOB: __________________Age ______
Sex:M / F Address: ___________________________________________ Preferred Phone: ________
Are you a college student?Yes / No / FT / PTAre you employed? Yes / No / FT / PT
Name of your employer and/or school and occupation: __________________________________
Significant relationship status (check one):☐single ☐engaged ☐married ☐separated ☐divorced ☐committed relationship ☐other _____________________
If married, spouse’s name, age, occupation:____________________________________________
Those with whom you are now living (list people): ________________________________________
Where you reside: ☐house (☐own ☐rent) ☐hotel☐room☐apartment ☐other____________
By whom were you referred?_________________________________________________________
PRESENTING PROBLEM(s):
Reason for seeking help now:
Depression symptoms (check all that apply):
__ Depressed mood most of the day, nearly every day (e.g., sad, empty, tearful);
__ Markedly diminished interest or pleasure in almost all activities most of the day, nearly every day;
__ Appetite/Weight changes: More than 5% change in weight OR decrease or increase in appetite nearly every day;
__ Insomnia or hypersomnia nearly every day;__ Psychomotor agitation or retardation nearly every day;
__ Fatigue or loss of energy nearly every day;__ Feelings of worthlessness, excessive/inappropriate guilt nearly daily;
__ Diminished ability to concentrate OR indecisiveness, nearly every day;__Recurrent thoughts of death or suicide.
Anxiety symptoms (check all that apply):
__excessive worry; __restlessness; __easily fatigued; __difficulty concentrating; __mind going blank; __poor memory; __irritability; __ muscle tension; __sleep disturbance; __GI Sx’s; __headaches; __frequent thoughts of danger; __avoidance of situations that produce anxiety; __easily startled; __feeling overwhelmed and unable to cope; __other:____________________________________________
Obsessive or ritualistic beh/cog which interfere with routine activities? Yes / No ________________
Hx of Panic attacks? Yes / No.If yes, when
Panic Sx: Racing heart / sense of terror / sweaty / chills / chest pain, tightness / SOB / loss of control / weakness, dizzy, faint / tingling or numbness in hands, fingers, limbs
Impulsivity problems? Y / N:spending / sexual / food / alcohol / drugs / video games / gambling/
Hx of manic episode (observable by others; at least one week)? Yes / No.If yes, when:
Grandiosity / decreased need for sleep / more talkative, pressured speech / racing thoughts / easily distracted / increase in goal-directed behavior / psychomotor agitation / excessive pleasurable risky activity
Are symptoms recurrent/intermittent?Yes/ No _____________________________
Frequency/Severity of symptoms: ________________________________
Onset of symptoms:___ Rapid, as of: _____________________;___ Gradual, as of: ____________
PSYCH HISTORY:
Previous counseling: Yes / No.Indiv / marital / family.When/how long? ___________
Focus/gains?____________________________
Prior diagnoses: _________________.
Prior psychotropic Rx: ____________
Current psych Rx: ___________
Family Hx of mental illness/ suicide / substance abuse? Paternal:________________________________________________________________.
Maternal: _________________________________________________________________.
MINI MENTAL STATUS EXAM: (Check all that apply)
Orientation: ___Oriented to time, place, person, circumstance;____ Disoriented to _________________________
Psychomotor activity: ___Normal;___ Accelerated;___Retarded;____Restless/Fidgety;___Rigid posture;
Interaction: open / forthcoming / guarded / gamey / oppositional / ________________
Appearance: Grooming: _____________ Dress: ____________ Weight: _______________; Age: older/younger/as stated.
Eye Contact: good / fair / poor / variable Mood: Today ______________ Past month: __________
Speech: normal / loud / soft / slurred / stereotyped / rapid / pressured / extended latencies / ________
Affect: congruent / inappropriate / full / labile / blunted / constricted/ flat / _____________
Appears: anxious/ depressed/ manic/ _______________________
Thought Process: WNL/ logical / illogical / loose associations / tangential/ circumstantial / paranoid /
suspicious / hallucinations (visual/ auditory/ olfactory/ tactile) / delusions / obsessive /
preoccupation with: ____________________
Complaints about attention/concentration?Yes / NoComplaints about memory? Yes / No
Judgment: Intact / ___________ impairment ______________________Insight: Poor / Fair / Good
NOTES:
SAFETY ASSESSMENT:
Current abuse or violence in the home?
Sexual abuse? Y / NPhysical abuse? Y / NVerbal abuse?Y / NNeglect?Y / N
Abuse or neglect involving a child, elder, or disabled person? ___ Denies; ___Yes:
Current Suicide Risk: ___ Low; ___ Mod; ___ High; ______ Imminent (plan and intent)
History of prior suicide attempt(s)? Yes / No. If yes,
History of prior suicide plan with intent? Yes / No.If yes,
Violence to Others Risk: ___ Low; ___ Mod;___ High; ______ Imminent (plan and intent)
Current homicidal thoughts? Yes/ no.Hx of homicidal thoughts? Yes/ no.
History of violence to others? Yes/ no. If yes,
Current Substance Use: Current Substance Abuse? Yes / No
Alcohol:
Tobacco: ____ Caffeine:
Cannabis: ______ Other:
Past substance abuse?Yes / No If yes,
Self-Harm Behaviors:Denies / Past / Present
Age of onset: _______________________________ Duration: _______________________________________________
Frequency: _________________________________ Location(s) on body: ______________________________________
Severity:__________________________________________ Received Medical Attention? Yes / No
Disordered eating/ body image/ exercise:
History of: binging/ purging / laxatives / diet pills / severe restricting / extreme exercise
Current body image?ExcellentGoodFairPoor
Current interference in lifestyle or well-being by weight/body/appearance concerns?
PHYSICAL HEALTH:Client’s overall rating:ExcellentGoodFairPoor
Chronic illnesses:
Chronic pain? Yes / No /
Surgeries:
Current Rx (non-psych):
Last physical: ___Name of physician:
Avg physical exercise per week:
Sleep: Avg _____ hrs/night; Insomnia? Yes / no / past / present.If yes: onset / mid / terminal.
Sleep meds used?
EDUC/OCCUP HISTORY:
Education: Highest grade completed: __________ Advanced degree(s)
Schooling: Public/ Private/ HomeLearning disability or ADHD?
Typical academic performance?Below avg / average / advanced
Currently in school? ___ No; ___Yes:
Occupation: Currently employed?Yes / No / FT / PT / Job searching.Hrs per week:
Current Emp: ___________________________________________________; ______________ Months / Years
Prior Emp: ________________________________________; _______ Months / Years
Prior Emp: ________________________________________; _______ Months / Years
FAMILY:
Grew up where?
Primarily raised by whom?
Siblings? Close with?
Conflict with?
Current Family/Relationships:
In a committed relationship?
Married or cohabiting? Yes / No.Divorced? Yes / No. Previous marriages? Yes / No:
Children? Yes / No _
TRAUMA/ABUSE HISTORY:
Emotional/verbal abuse? _____
Sexual abuse/assault? ____
Physical abuse? _____
Neglect? ________Bullying? ___________
Have you ever been in a situation in which you felt you were going to die or be seriously injured? Yes / No
Any significant motor vehicle accidents, head injuries, knocked unconscious, fires/natural disasters? Yes / No
Other experience you would consider “traumatic”?Yes / No.
If yes: _________
LEGAL HISTORY:
Do you have any past or current involvement with the legal system (e.g., warrants, arrests, detentions, convictions, probation, parole)?_______________________
Do you have any past or current involvement with the court system (e.g., family court, workers compensation dispute, civil litigation, court-ordered psychiatric treatment)?_______________
STRENGTHS/SUPPORTS/LIFESTYLE:
Client’s Perceived Strengths:Ability to articulate: readily / slowly / with great difficulty
1) ____________; 2) __________; 3) ____________
Words that describe your personality:
Social Support: ____ Sufficient;____ Limited;____ Lacking
Primarily supported by:
Social organizations/groups:
Conflict in close relationships: Low / Moderate / High
Hobbies/Leisure Activities: _____________
Spirituality/Religion: Spiritual resources requested? Yes / No ___
Current description/affiliation:____________
Raised how? ______________________________Hx of harmful religious experiences? Yes / No
OTHER: Anything we haven’t discussed that you feel I should know about? _______
What improvements do you hope will result from counseling? _________
Ideas of how long you expect to be in counseling? _____________
DIAGNOSTIC IMPRESSION:
Axis I: ________________________________
Axis II:_______________________________
Axis III: (Medical) _____________
Axis IV: (Situational) ____________________
Axis V: (GAF; Current) _____________Overall symptom severity: mild / moderate / severe / variable
Impairment:Social: _____Little or none;____Mild;____ Moderate;____ Acute/Severe;___ Variable
Educ/Occup: _____Little or none;____Mild;____ Moderate;____ Acute/Severe;___ Variable
ADL’s: _____Little or none;____Mild;____ Moderate;____ Acute/Severe;___ Variable
PLAN:
______ Begin psychotherapy w/this author.
Freq/duration: ___________________________
Initial Goals/Focus: _________________________
_____ Other: Recommended:
Referral:
Signed:__________________________________________________________
Clinician Date
- Visit the Queendom.com or Psychtests.com website and complete two tests.
Post a response to the following:
- After reviewing the sample clinical interview and Jones (2010) article, describe which sections you feel are most critical to explore and why. Which do you feel are unnecessary? Why?
- Compare and contrast the two tests selected in terms of reliability and validity.
- Do you feel confident in the results of each test selected? Why or why not?
- When considering the limitations of clinical interviews presented in your text, how do clinical tests fill the gaps in the diagnostic process?
Assignment: Advantages and Disadvantages of Diagnosis and Labeling
Clinicians make use of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (5th ed.; DSM-5) classification system to make diagnoses that will guide the choice of a treatment approach. As you read in Fundamentals of Abnormal Psychology, however, the practice of diagnosing clients and the use of diagnostic categories and labels are sometimes subject to criticism. Some argue that diagnostic labels can cause harm. Others disagree, stating that diagnosis is an essential step in the clinical process as the clinician proceeds from assessment to diagnosis to treatment. In this week’s Assignment, you will evaluate both advantages and disadvantages of the practice of diagnosing and labeling psychological disorders. You will decide whether or not you are convinced that current diagnostic practices are acceptable.
To prepare for this Assignment:
Review the Learning Resources, paying close attention to diagnosis and classification in mental health settings. Note any specific advantages and disadvantages of the process of diagnosing and classification.
https://www.apa.org/science/programs/testing/index
The Assignment (2–3 pages):
- Evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of diagnosing and classifying psychological disorders. Include in your evaluation responses to the following prompts:
- Evaluate the advantages of diagnosis and classification in mental health settings. Be specific and provide examples where appropriate.
- Evaluate the disadvantages of diagnosis and classification in mental health settings. Be specific and provide examples where appropriate.
- From a multicultural perspective, explain what issues might arise with respect to the assessment and diagnosis of individuals from different cultural backgrounds (review this table in the textbook: Multicultural Hot Spots in Assessment and Diagnosis).
- Finally, based on your evaluations in the prior prompts, explain your position regarding the relative advantages and disadvantages of current diagnostic and classification practices, including an assessment of whether you believe the advantages outweigh the disadvantages or vice versa. Be sure to support your position.
"You need a similar assignment done from scratch? Our qualified writers will help you with a guaranteed AI-free & plagiarism-free A+ quality paper, Confidentiality, Timely delivery & Livechat/phone Support.
Discount Code: CIPD30
Click ORDER NOW..
